Op. 10 No. 3


My intention was to write about the sonatas in order, so I apologize that I’m jumping ahead a little here. After the Op. 7 sonata there are the Op. 10 Nos. 1 and 2 before this one, but I’m recording the Op. 10 No. 3 next week and this is a great way for me to get really into the piece, to get the imagination going, and to have to do the much revered basement pre-recording. So here we go, Op. 10 No. 3 in D Major.


Before getting to the actual sonata, I would like to ponder for a few moments on something I think I missed about the very first sonata, Op. 2 No. 1. As I mentioned, there is the same “rocket” in that sonata:

as is in a Symphony by Mozart:

I wrote mostly about what makes the Beethoven “rocket” so different from the Mozart one, but after having spent even more time with the sonatas, I am quite sure that Beethoven meant to quote Mozart as an homage to his, well, musical idol.

We have examples like this in many pieces, one of my favorite musical quote is in Leonard Bernstein’s wonderful, wonderful West Side Story. Listen to when the words “there’s a place for us…” is sung:

(This is from the movie from the 60s I think…it is phenomenal, and if you haven’t seen it, do!)

Now, this little phrase “There’s a place…” is “stolen” from who? Ehhh, Beethoven, of course. This is the Emperor Concerto, slow movement. Listen at 0.25, there it is…

This is not Bernstein running out of his own melodies, and he had to cheat. This is a little moment of love for Beethoven shown by Bernstein in his music, a little celebration if you want. Just as Beethoven did to Mozart in his first notes in his first sonata.


This was a little bit of a sidetrack to the op. 10 No. 3 sonata, but not entirely. Because what Beethoven did, what Bernstein did, was to use, and to play with motives (dictionary is for those who want to know what motive is).
And playing with a motive is what Beethoven does in the first movement of this Sonata. And he does it, as he so often does with things, in absurdum.


The first movement starts like this:

It’s quite a an exciting beginning, full of energy and life. And it gets even more entertaining if you compare the beginning with the last movement, the end, of the sonata before this one in the Op. 10, the No. 2. It starts like this:

Like an someone laughing in a theatrical way, or operatic way. And of course, since it’s Beethoven, he does it…in absurdum…he does it for the WHOLE movement. It goes on and on til the end.

So, what does Beethoven do with the very next sonata? He begins it in the same way, the “laughing”. But now, he does something completely different. He stops it with an accent, BAM, just like that, without a reason, really. And it makes quite an effect, a kind of “what the heck will happen now?”-moment:

I will get a little technical here, but it’s fun and has a purpose: What you just heard was, in essence:

1) Octaves (meaning there are no harmonies, just ALWAYS the same notes played at the same time: first there are three D:s, then three C#s, etc.)

2) There is only one voice (stämma in Swedish)

3) Short notes, which is called staccato

4) Basically an upward motion



Let’s take a look, or a hearing rather, at what happens next:

Here we have the following:

1) ALL the steps in the motion are now chords, instead of octaves

2) several voices

3) sustained, connected notes, which is called legato

4) a downward motion

Just everything, everything is upside down in comparison with the first seconds of the sonata…and yet…when you put them together, it they fit quite well together:

How is that possible?


It is possible because Beethoven takes a little motive, the very first four notes taken from the beginning:

And uses it in the downward motion, listen to the “one-two-three-four-one-two-three-four” going down in steps:

And this is only the beginning, to say the least. Beethoven will use this little four-note motive, which by itself is nothing (really, nothing) and use it in every which way throughout the whole first movement. In no other sonata movement will Beethoven be this extreme in using the same motive over and over again.


I love how Beethoven “restarts” the octave-laughing theme and this time he stops it again, but in another, much more dramatic way.

An what comes after that? NOT what one would expect after that dramatic gesture. It’s a pretty melody, bubbly, almost childish:

This is typical of this movement. The music turns and twist, it’s surprising and entertaining, exciting and energetic – without no real melodies or themes.

Let’s continue from where we ended the last clip and hear the second theme, which shows up at 0.11 :

Not too much to write home about perhaps…if it was not for the humorous quality: the first four notes…

are the famous first little notes

…but he now plays them in double speed.

And this:

is a little variation of the first “one-two-three-four”-theme, the first four notes. But this one is played in HALF the speed.


To continue, listen to the left hand, the lower part at 0.06 and forward. The little four notes are there constantly…


And listen to this, a variation of the four notes, over and over again…

To finish the piece, Beethoven kind of rolls the music like a snowball rolling down a hill getting larger and larger and then Bang!, we’re at the end.

We have a piece of music that is so exciting, built on the simplest motive you can ever imagine.

Beethoven sometimes strikes me like a magician, who asks his audience “who can give me the simplest, silliest motive?”. He then takes it and makes great music out of it.


On a slightly philosophical note, isn’t this something really great in itself? To take something “common”, and make something “special”? When I hear a melody of Mozart and Schubert I feel like I am entering holy ground. But isn’t fulfillment in life based on being able to see the beauty of every-day things? Things we do or see all the time?

6 thoughts on “Op. 10 No. 3

  1. Yes Per, West Side Story is very obvious. Do you recognize Haydn´s music somewhere here as well? And how did Goethe influence Beethoven do you think?
    I agree with you that to be able to see the beauty in every-day life that´s great. And to give it to others that´s even greater!

  2. Immediately after the “there’s a place for us” melody in the Emperor sonata is a theme that’s just too reminiscent of a rock tune with the lyrics “and I can’t help, I can’t help, I can’t help falling in love with you.”
    On searching I find it’s an Elvis tune associated with Plaisir d’amour and Berlioz.
    It will be interesting to make a timeline of it.

    1. Schuman also quotes the last mvt of the Emperor concerto first theme part b in the last section of carnival(in the minor).the phillistines and davidsbundlers-rehearsal 25 in score.c minor.

  3. I only found this site last week! I am listening through all Beethoven sonatas, one per day, starting last week. I had always wanted to do this and decided that the only way to do it, is to make a project of it (I have heard many of the sonatas performed live and I play piano myself, but these are above my capabilities, except the 2 short ones of course). So I’m listening with and without the scores and making notes, etc. I also listen to all the Andras Schiff lectures, and I love those as well. Do you know what’s odd? Your name is not on this blog?! But I found your FB page, so now I know.

    This site/blog is a great resource – thank you for putting it together! So many of these sonatas are so rarely performed, which is really too bad. I am greatly inspired by the different pianists who are now working on playing them all, it’s suddenly the big thing to do, but it will reach more people and more people will start thinking about this amazing music – hurray.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s